Skip to the main content

Non-owner car insurance in Indiana

When you borrow or rent a car, this covers the harm you do to others, and it’s issued in your name. Get it if you drive in most months or need an SR-22 but own no car. Join the owner's policy if you live with them instead.

A driver at the wheel of a borrowed car on an open highway

1 of 2

How old are you?

What companies offer non-owner insurance in Indiana?

Here, prices were collected for 8 companies, with the cheapest listed first. USAA charges $103 and is open only to military families.

CompanyPer yearPer month
Auto-Owners logoAuto-Owners$83$7
USAA logoUSAA (military families)$103$9
Indiana Farm Bureau logoIndiana Farm Bureau$211$18
Travelers logoTravelers$290$24
Indiana Farmers Insurance logoIndiana Farmers$344$29
GEICO logoGEICO$383$32
Progressive logoProgressive$497$41
Farmers logoFarmers$677$56

Auto-Owners is listed at $83 a year, far below the other companies here. That is the study's figure, so ask an agent for a real quote before counting on it.

These company prices are for a 40-year-old with a clean record, so your own answers above can give a different price. Indiana ranks 9th lowest in cost among the 50 states, based on a rate study that used the same driver profile as the prices shown. Which companies sell it in Indiana.

A friend hands car keys to a driver in a driveway

A Certificate of Compliance is typically the first thing Indiana asks for; an SR22 enters the picture only after that. Unless you decline them in writing, uninsured and underinsured motorist protections come with every policy here.

The minimum limits in Indiana, along with two default coverages

The state minimum appears as 25/50/25 on this BMV financial responsibility page. That works out to $25,000 for one person hurt and $50,000 for two or more people hurt. For property damage, the lowest amount you can carry is $25,000 per accident. That money goes to pay the people you injure and the property you hit.

You receive two protections that are included automatically. After a collision with a driver who has no insurance, uninsured motorist coverage steps in; it is included at 25/50 and adds $25,000 for property damage. When the other driver's policy is too small, underinsured motorist coverage helps, starting at $50,000. Either coverage can be declined, provided you do so in writing.

Indiana’s proof steps: COC comes before the SR22

A letter goes out from the Indiana Bureau of Motor Vehicles (BMV) after a reported crash or certain traffic tickets. A pointable moving violation received within a year of two others is one such case. The Indiana Department of Insurance auto page says your agent files the Certificate of Compliance (COC) after a crash or violation. The form must reach the BMV no later than 90 days afterward.

Did you lack insurance on that date? If so, the BMV requires an SR22, which is a filing your insurer makes to verify you now have coverage. The SR22 keeps your insurance suspension on hold, according to the BMV reinstatement page. If you hold it without any gap for 180 consecutive days, the suspension is lifted. Without a car of your own, a non-owner policy can carry it for you.

Fees for SR22 cancellation and reinstatement in Indiana

Drivers cannot send policy papers straight to the BMV. Proof can only come from your insurer, and it is sent electronically. Your driving privileges are suspended if the BMV receives an SR26, which is the insurer's alert that an SR22 is ending. A lapse in your SR22 at any time during the required window triggers the same result.

Your official driving record lists the fee for each suspension, and getting a copy is $4. The BMV suspension and insurance forms page lets you pay your reinstatement fees by mail, phone, the internet, or a 24-hour kiosk.

Cost by age in Indiana

For teens, the yearly cost is around $846. For a 40-year-old, minimum coverage on an owned car costs an average of $506 per year, which is about $186 above a non-owner policy at $320.

AgeMenWomen
16 to 19$866$825
20 to 24$477$467
25 to 64$319$327
65 and over$348$336

All figures are annual, for a clean record and the lowest required limits. The rates for ages 25 through 64 draw from the study’s 25‑to‑60 bracket; the 65‑and‑older group uses its 65‑to‑75 data.

Get a non-owner quote in Indiana

A licensed agent who writes policies in Indiana takes your call, goes through how you drive for free, and gets you real quotes right away.

Call 833-958-5598

Or ask for a call back

Costs in surrounding states